Moving Beyond AngerFebruary 21, 2006
Christine Rosen has a good column at the Wall Street Journal about the level of anger in spiritual memoirs. Here are a few highlights:
Recent decades have seen the growth of spiritual memoirs.Amen! While it is okay to point out disagreements, hopefully the level of anger and bitterness can be lessened. We need more works that focus on the positives of our faith.
... These days, the spiritual-memoir genre takes many different forms, some of them sensationalist or written with the intention of demonstrating a particular faith's weaknesses or dangers.
... Indeed, critics are generally inclined to hail the honesty of a person who leaves a religious community, seeing their own values in the individual's embrace of a secular life. These same critics are generally less enthusiastic about books in which the authors find faith for the first time or return to it after a hiatus.
Still, not all writers of spiritual memoir are indulging in religious schadenfreude.
... For whatever reason, many writers of spiritual memoir find themselves unable to move beyond anger or an eagerness to use their work as a springboard for a broader condemnation of people of faith. Writers of memoir generally must be true to their experience, of course, but spiritual memoirists face an especially daunting task. The faith they describe is not theirs alone--it is shared by many. That makes writing in good faith all the more challenging.